Our roofers are insured by a $5 million dollar general liability insurance. Fully compliant & in good standing with WBC.

5 Ways Your Insurance Company Avoids Paying For Your Roof Claim

Dealing with insurance companies and filing roof claims can be a daunting task. Often, homeowners face challenges when it comes to getting their insurance company to cover the cost of roof repairs or replacements. In this article, we will explore the most common tactics insurance companies use to avoid paying for roof claims and provide you with valuable information to protect yourself. By understanding these tactics and knowing what to look for in your insurance policy, you can ensure that you are prepared and equipped to handle any disputes that may arise.

1. Raising Your Deductible

The first tactic insurance companies use is raising your deductible. By increasing your out-of-pocket expenses, insurance companies shift the burden of the cost onto homeowners. While it may seem reasonable to have a higher deductible, insurance companies often inform homeowners of this change in lengthy policy renewal documents that often go unnoticed. It is crucial to carefully review your policy every year to ensure you are aware of any changes in your deductible. While understanding the changes in your deductible is vital, it’s also important to take proactive steps to protect your roof; discover the best 12 ways to proactively protect your roof to potentially minimize the need for costly repairs.

2. Denying the Claim

Another strategy employed by insurance companies is outright denial of a roof claim. Insurance companies may deny a claim based on various grounds, such as insufficient damage or high claim volumes in a particular area. Homeowners often trust the adjuster’s verdict and accept the denial without questioning it. However, it is essential to advocate for yourself and seek professional opinions if you believe your claim has been wrongfully denied. If your roof claim has been denied, it’s crucial to know the immediate steps to take; read about the 7 steps to take when roof damage is detected to ensure you’re fully prepared to handle this situation.

3. Fighting with Your Contractor

Insurance companies may engage in battles with your chosen contractor to delay or reduce payment. These disputes can range from challenging specific line items in the contractor’s estimate to disputing prices. Insurance companies often have greater resources and use these tactics to wear down the contractor, hoping they will accept a lower payment. As a homeowner, it is crucial to be aware of these tactics and support your contractor throughout the claim process.

4. Prorating Replacement Coverage

Prorating replacement coverage is another method used by insurance companies. Traditionally, insurance policies have provided 100% coverage for replacing damaged property. However, some companies have started prorating coverage, reducing the amount homeowners receive for replacement over time. This means that if your roof is ten years old and you file a claim, you may only receive a fraction of the replacement cost. It is vital to understand the terms of your policy and advocate for comprehensive coverage.

5. Cosmetic Exclusions

Cosmetic exclusions are a concerning trend in the insurance industry. Insurance companies may refuse to pay for cosmetic damage, such as dented vents or gutter systems, even if they are functioning correctly. Some companies have extended this exclusion to entire roofs, leaving homeowners responsible for significant repair costs. It is crucial to examine your policy carefully to determine if it contains any cosmetic exclusions and seek clarification from your insurer.

Protecting Yourself

1. Understand Your Policy Language

To safeguard yourself against insurance companies avoiding payment for roof claims, carefully review your policy. Look for absolute or inclusive language that states what is and isn’t covered. Phrases like “always,” “never,” “and,” or “or” can provide insight into the extent of your coverage.

2. Document and Gather Evidence

In the event of roof damage, document everything thoroughly to support your claim. Take detailed notes, capture photographs of the damage, and organize any relevant receipts or paperwork. This evidence will serve as proof in your claim and strengthen your case against the insurance company. When documenting any damage, it’s essential to know what to look for; our guide on how to inspect your roof for hail damage can help you identify and document key issues effectively.

3. Contact Your Insurance Representative

Notify your insurance company about the damage as soon as it is safe to do so. Provide accurate and complete details about the circumstances and any subsequent damage. Keep a record of all communication, including the names of representatives you spoke with and their contact information.

4. File a Proof of Loss

If requested by your insurance company, complete a “proof of loss” form listing all damaged or lost property with their corresponding values or costs. Sign the form, affirming the truthfulness of the statements made. Submit this form within the specified timeframe to avoid potential claim denial.

5. Appeal a Denied Claim

If your claim is denied, you have the right to appeal the decision. Always submit your appeal in writing and request a resolution date to expedite the process. Insurance companies may send another adjuster for a second opinion during the appeals process.


Understanding the tactics insurance companies use to avoid paying for roof claims and taking proactive steps to protect yourself are essential. By familiarizing yourself with your policy, documenting damage, gathering evidence, and advocating for your rights, you can increase the chances of a successful claim. Remember to reach out to professionals for guidance and support throughout the process. When seeking guidance and support from roofing professionals, make sure to ask the right questions; learn 4 questions to ask a roofer before signing a roofing contract to make an informed decision. Stay vigilant, ask questions, and don’t hesitate to challenge an insurance company’s decision if you believe it is unjust.

In the wake of navigating through your roof claim, remember that local support is close at hand. No matter where you are in the Vancouver area, a trusted roofer is nearby. If you need a Burnaby Roofers, New Westminster Roofers, Coquitlam Roofers, Port Coquitlam Roofers, Port Moody Roofers, Delta Roofers, Ladner Roofers, Vancouver Roofers, North Vancouver Roofers, West Vancouver Roofers, Richmond Roofers, Surrey Roofers, White Rock Roofers, Maple Ridge Roofers, Pitt Meadows Roofers, or Langley Roofers, our experts are on standby to deliver top-tier service and advice. Reach out to us today, and let us arm you with a solid roofing solution that stands up to the challenges of both weather and insurance claims. Your home deserves the best defense, and with our professionals, that’s precisely what you’ll get.

Table of Contents